Tuesday 14 August 2007

At the Library...

Reading an interesting book by sociologist Robert Puttnam which has some interesting links to the work we do and made me think about the future of small local organisations. In Bowling Alone: America's Declining Social Capital Putnam surveys the decline of "social capital" in the United States of America since 1950, which he feels undermines the active civil engagement a strong democracy requires from its citizens. Putnam discusses ways in which Americans have disengaged from political involvement including decreased voter turnout, public meeting attendance, serving on committees and working with political parties. Putnam notes the aggregate loss in membership of many civic organizations and points out that membership has not migrated to other organizations. To illustrate why the decline in Americans' membership in social organizations is problematic to democracy, Putnam uses bowling as an example. Although the number of people who bowl has increased in the last 20 years, the number of people that bowl in leagues has decreased. Since people bowl alone they do not participate in social interaction and civic discussions that might occur in a league environment.
Putnam then contrasts the countertrends of ever increasing mass-membership organizations, nonprofit organizations and support groups to the data of the General Social Survey. This data shows an aggregate decline in membership of traditional civic organizations, proving his thesis that the social capital of the US has declined. He then asks the obvious question "Why is US social capital eroding?" Putnam suggests closer studies of which forms of associations can create the greatest social capital, how various aspects of technology, changes in social equality, and public policy affect social capital. He closes by emphasizing the importance of discovering how the United States could reverse the trend of social capital decay. So there you have it!!

1 comment:

Paul Rideout said...

Good summary of Putnam’s sociological insight into the decline of social capital in the USA, and good to hear you’re visiting the local library.

Putnam’s insight is now influencing the thinking of people here in the UK. Not a bad thing as it has (as you say) interesting links to the work HVA do and made you think about the future of small local organisations.

It is good that Putnam’s insight has encouraged people to think about the concept of a declining of social capital.

What is worrying is that people may try to import Putnam’s examples of decline and potential remedies to the UK.

The USA and the UK have two distinct social histories, each with specific mechanisms for developing and supporting local communities (of either interest or geography).

Ideally the focus needs to be on developing trust and community engagement based on the aspirations of local people and local communities here in the UK.

So Putnam’s a good read, but we should aspire to think local and act local in developing our social capital.